Matthew and Toby don’t have a lot to talk about thanks to the All Star break, but they find time to cover David Ortiz’s recent transgressions, theorize about Mike Pence’s baseball affiliations, fantasize about eating one of the Diamondbacks' new concession items (a 3-pound ice cream helmet featuring multiple brownies), and completely butcher Edwin Encarnacion’s name. And it’s a particularly half-hearted attempt at empathy this time with Royals fan James Hupp, who talks about what it's like to win a World Series after years of being terrible and relays the epic incident of George Brett and the pine tar bat.